FANDOM


Replacement filing cabinet This page is an archive. Please do not edit the contents of this page, other than for maintenance.

Remington_870 (history - links - logs) Edit

The Remington 870 as well as the Remington 870 MCS pages appear to, in my opinion, fall under a discussion held elsewhere to do with the fact that similarly functioning, similarly named weapons should be in the same article. As it stands, we have the cut R870 MCS on the R870 page, while the BO2 MCS has a page to itself.

Delete Edit

Keep Edit

Pictogram voting keep Keep — they look and act quite different. ive used the black ops ds version myself, so i know. you can see a picture of it on the remington 870 page, it looks very different, and again it has some different stats. War flag of the Imperial Japanese Army RisingSun2020 Personal RisingSun2013 2000px-Flag of JSDF.svg (RisingSun's Talk Page Blog Posts Contributions) 01:52, December 3, 2015 (UTC)

Split/Merge Edit

Pictogram voting merge Merge — As nominator SteveHeist (talk) 16:09, December 1, 2015 (UTC)

Comments/Questions Edit

Pictogram voting comment Comment — Ok, Rising, I understand your point. But, at the very least, could we move the MW2 cut weapon, named R870 MCS into the MCS page? If we leave the BODS one behind, I could understand. SteveHeist (talk) December 3, 2015 (Wikitext doesn't want to work)

if its actually called r870 mcs, then that info should definitely be moved to the remington 870 mcs page. ill do that now. War flag of the Imperial Japanese Army RisingSun2020 Personal RisingSun2013 2000px-Flag of JSDF.svg (RisingSun's Talk Page Blog Posts Contributions) 02:54, December 26, 2015 (UTC)

Pictogram voting comment Comment — I'm hesitant on this one, considering that they don't have a lot of differences, and we have some similar cases where pages are merged, such as M9/M9A1. However, if the 870 functions differently enough from the 870 MCS then I guess they should remain separated. Kilo 141 Beta menu icon MW Ultimate94ninja talk · contribs 10:40, January 12, 2016 (UTC)

other than having similar names and the same magazine capacity, theyre pretty different. they look different and the remington 870 is technically semi-auto, to name some of the major differences. if they were named the same, id say put them together, but the differences are just too major. War flag of the Imperial Japanese Army RisingSun2020 Personal RisingSun2013 2000px-Flag of JSDF.svg (RisingSun's Talk Page Blog Posts Contributions) 01:47, January 14, 2016 (UTC)

Closed - several months with inactivity, i forgot that this was basically sorted out: instead of the whole pae being merged, only the mw2 info was merged with the r870 mcs page. War flag of the Imperial Japanese Army RisingSun2020 Personal RisingSun2013 2000px-Flag of JSDF.svg (RisingSun's Talk Page Blog Posts Contributions) 22:44, April 17, 2016 (UTC)

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.